[chirp_devel] [PATCH] [New Model] Support for the BTECH Mobile Radios, fixes issue #3015

Dan Smith
Thu Mar 24 19:03:50 PDT 2016


>> It would certainly kinda suck to penalize everyone just so that
>> the preprod radios work under their rightful name.
> 
> But we can do it right from the beginning!
> 
> We can put the magic for the pre-prod/alphas/unique radios *at the
> end*, and 99.9% of the users will be straight in the first try to the
> clone mode with ZERO delay.
> 
> The users with a pre-prod/alphas/unique radios will have to wait a 
> little more (with some room for improvement) and ... it's not the
> worst thing in the world ;-)

Sorry, but I do not think that putting the magics we think are rare at
the end and encountering a delay if so is doing it "right from the
beginning." Even if it's 0.1% right now, we know the manufacturer(s) are
going to continue to release radios based on this from previous experience.

> As a principle this radios must be a very small lot, so affected
> users will be a very small quantity compared with the other real
> market users.

I don't think this is a good argument. Unless there is a good reason not
to, I'd much prefer to have a repeatable process where we go straight to
the radio class we need, send the magic string we need, and fail quickly
if it's the wrong one.

> And if we look closer we have just ONE radio with this problem so
> far.

If it's literally one preprod sample radio, then we shouldn't put it in
CHIRP at all anyway.

--Dan



More information about the chirp_devel mailing list